Getting started · For the both

The Courts of Orange County: Which One Hears Your Case

Before you file or answer anything in Orange County, you need to know which court the case belongs in. New York splits civil cases between Supreme Court, the state's general trial court, and lower courts that handle smaller money claims. Orange County cases are typically heard in Goshen; confirm the assigned justice's part rules before filing motions.

Supreme Court, Orange County

Supreme Court hears larger money claims and anything that needs equitable relief: injunctions, specific performance, business dissolution, real property disputes and complex commercial cases. Most merchant cash advance and guaranty lawsuits are filed here. Each case is assigned to a justice who manages it through discovery, motions and trial.

District, city, town and village courts

Smaller money disputes go to City courts in Newburgh, Middletown and Port Jervis, plus town and village justice courts. These courts handle unpaid invoices, consumer debt collection, security deposits and contract claims below their monetary limit. Procedure is lighter and cases move faster than in Supreme Court.

Specialty parts

Small claims parts let individuals bring modest claims without a lawyer, and commercial claims parts let small businesses do the same. Housing matters, estates and family matters each have their own courts or parts.

Common questions

Which court do I file in for a business dispute in Orange County?
It depends on the amount and the relief you want. Claims above about $15,000, or that need an injunction, go to Supreme Court; smaller money claims go to the lower court.
Does filing in the wrong court end my case?
Usually not on the merits, but it can mean dismissal, transfer, extra fees and lost months.

Have a matter in Orange County?

Tell us what happened and we will tell you where it belongs, what the deadline is, and what it will cost. We respond within the hour during business hours.

Related guides

This guide is general information about court procedure in Orange County, New York. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Court rules, fees and deadlines change — confirm current requirements with the court or an attorney before acting. Dispute Counsel PLLC serves New York residents, businesses and New York local representation.