Can I get more time to answer?

Often, yes, by written stipulation with the plaintiff's lawyer or by court order. Get it in writing before the deadline.

Do I need a lawyer to answer?

Individuals can represent themselves, but corporations and LLCs generally must appear through an attorney in Supreme Court.

Defending a case · For the defendant

Answering a Summons in Erie County (Buffalo)

If you were served with a summons and complaint in Erie County (Buffalo), the deadline to respond started the day service was completed. The answer is where you deny allegations, raise defenses and preserve counterclaims.

Step one: write down the dates

Record the date and method of service. If papers were left with someone else or mailed, service may not be complete until proof of service is filed. Don't guess — calculate the deadline conservatively.

What goes in the answer

Respond to each numbered paragraph by admitting, denying, or stating you lack knowledge. Then list affirmative defenses such as lack of personal jurisdiction, statute of limitations, payment, usury, or failure to state a claim, along with any counterclaims.

Motion to dismiss as an alternative

If the complaint is defective — wrong court, improper service, time-barred, or legally insufficient — a pre-answer motion to dismiss can end or narrow the case early.

Common questions

Can I get more time to answer?: Often, yes, by written stipulation with the plaintiff's lawyer or by court order. Get it in writing before the deadline.
Do I need a lawyer to answer?: Individuals can represent themselves, but corporations and LLCs generally must appear through an attorney in Supreme Court.

Have a matter in Erie County (Buffalo)?

Tell us what happened and we will tell you where it belongs, what the deadline is, and what it will cost. We respond within the hour during business hours.

Start your intake intake@dispute-counsel.com

Related guides

This guide is general information about court procedure in Erie County (Buffalo), New York. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Court rules, fees and deadlines change — confirm current requirements with the court or an attorney before acting. Dispute Counsel PLLC serves New York residents, businesses and New York local representation.